Urban Meyer would not have been cool, calm and collected on the Western Michigan sideline in Week 1.
The Broncos thought they had just pulled off the biggest upset in program history. They had gone into Michigan Stadium and beaten the Wolverines. The clock looked like it had hit zero as Bryce Underwood’s first Hail Mary sailed beyond the end zone.
Then the Big Ten review crew ruled Michigan still had one second.
Western Michigan had already started celebrating. Officials sent everyone back. Underwood got another throw. This time he connected with JJ Buchanan, and Michigan escaped 13-12.
It was controversial enough that the MAC asked the NCAA to overturn the result. The NCAA said it cannot change the outcome of a completed game.
Through all of that, Western Michigan stayed composed. Head coach Lance Taylor handled the moment with grace. Meyer said he would not have done the same.
What Meyer said on The Joel Klatt Show
Speaking on “The Joel Klatt Show,” the former Florida and Ohio State coach praised Western Michigan’s response — then separated that response from his own.
“I thought Western Michigan handled it as classy as they could,” Meyer said, via Thomas Goldkamp of On3. “I’m not saying I would have went there. I would have lost my mind, because I saw what I saw, there’s three zeros on the board and you celebrate.”
That quote is the story. Meyer is not saying Buchanan dropped the ball. He is saying the game looked over before Michigan got a second chance.
The play everyone is still arguing about
Here is the sequence that created the clip.
Michigan led 7-0 after the first drive, then went quiet. Western Michigan took a 12-7 lead late. Underwood had to throw a Hail Mary. The first one went out of the back of the end zone. The stadium clock showed zeros. Broncos players left the sideline. A lot of people watching, including Meyer, thought Western Michigan had won in the Big House.
Replay added a second. Michigan lined up again. Underwood threw a better ball. Buchanan, a Utah transfer, came down with it in the end zone.
The MAC did not argue that the second throw was incomplete. The protest was about whether that second should have existed. Big Ten officials stood by the review and said the replay showed time still on the clock when the first pass was touched.
Michigan left Ann Arbor 1-0. Western Michigan left with a one-point loss and no historic win.
Why Lance Taylor’s reaction stood out
Taylor did not melt down on television. He did not turn the postgame into a war with the conference. He took the loss in public without turning it into a circus.
That is what Meyer called classy.
It is also why Meyer’s contrast landed. Plenty of coaches would have said the same thing in private. Meyer said it on a national show. He drew a line between the way Western Michigan handled the night and the way he would have handled three zeros turning into one more Michigan snap.
Credit Michigan for converting the extra play. Most people on the other sideline will still say the Broncos should never have had to defend it.
Meyer’s history makes the quote louder
Meyer is not a neutral voice in a Michigan story. He won at Florida and Ohio State. He coached with an edge. He treated big-game moments as fights, not press releases.
That background is why the clip spread. Fans heard a coach who has stood on both sides of rivalry Saturdays say he would have lost his mind. They also heard him admit Western Michigan did the respectable thing.
Those two ideas can sit together. Taylor protected his program’s image. Meyer is saying he would have protected the moment.
The NCAA dead end
The MAC’s petition made the argument official. It did not change the standings.
Once a game is final, the NCAA does not have a clean path to flip the result because a conference disagrees with a replay ruling. That is why Michigan is still 1-0 and Western Michigan cannot put “beat Michigan in the Big House” on the résumé.
The on-field dispute is over. The argument about the second is not, because the visual was so clean for so many people: zeros on the board, a celebration, then another snap.
What the extra second did to both teams
For Michigan, the Hail Mary bought a win and a week of debate. It did not make the offense look settled. Underwood needed a miracle after a long stretch of stalled drives. Kyle Whittingham’s debut is in the win column. The tape is still messy.
For Western Michigan, the night became a near-miss that will follow the program. The Broncos played well enough to win in Ann Arbor. They celebrated. Then they had to watch Michigan use a second they did not think existed.
That is the part Meyer locked onto. He saw the celebration. He saw the zeros. He said he would not have gone quietly from there.
Week 2 will move the news cycle. The clip will linger.
Michigan hosts Oklahoma next. That game will decide whether the Hail Mary was a footnote or the start of a rocky Whittingham year. Western Michigan has to live with a loss that feels like a win that got taken back.
Eventually the calendar will do what the NCAA would not: push everyone to the next Saturday. Meyer’s comments keep the Week 1 ending alive a little longer, because they put a famous coach on the record.
Western Michigan handled it with class. Michigan took the second and the win. Meyer said if he had been the one watching three zeros turn into one more throw, he would have lost his mind.
Discover more from Allsportsreports
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
