Ohio State sits at 6-3 after consecutive losses to USC and Oregon. What began as a season with national championship expectations has turned into a fight to finish with dignity. The College Football Playoff window is essentially closed. Three regular-season games remain, and Ryan Day faces clear, interconnected problems that must be addressed immediately if the Buckeyes want to avoid further embarrassment and enter the offseason with any momentum.

Three issues stand above the rest: a defense that has collapsed, a quarterback situation forced by injury, and coaching decisions that have repeatedly failed to adjust when games slip away. Fixing even two of them would change the complexion of the final stretch. Leaving all three unaddressed risks a deeper spiral.
Problem 1: The Defense Has Become a Liability
Through the first seven games, Ohio State’s defense was serviceable. Over the last two it has been a major reason the team is losing. The Buckeyes have allowed 71 points in back-to-back games. Explosive plays have become routine. The pass rush is historically poor — only 11 sacks through nine games, among the lowest rates in the Power conferences.
Defensive coordinator Matt Patricia’s unit has struggled to generate consistent pressure and has failed to adjust when opponents found answers. Communication and fundamental alignment issues have been publicly acknowledged. When the offense stalls, the defense has been unable to force the stops needed to regain momentum. Oregon scored 38 unanswered points after Ohio State led 14-0. That kind of collapse does not happen to championship-caliber defenses.
Day has identified explosive plays as a glaring problem. Solving it requires more creative pressure packages, cleaner coverage responsibilities, and better in-game adjustments. The talent is still present. The execution and schematic responses have not matched the moment. Until the defense stops giving up big plays and starts getting off the field on third down, the Buckeyes will remain vulnerable no matter what happens on offense.
Problem 2: The Quarterback Situation and Julian Sayin’s Injury Reality
The single biggest on-field change this season has been the loss of starting quarterback Julian Sayin. Sayin suffered a significant injury to his throwing arm in the fourth quarter of the October 17 win at Indiana. He was sacked, his right arm was pinned awkwardly, and he left the game in a sling.
The latest updates paint a clear picture. Ryan Day has said Sayin is out indefinitely and that the program is planning as if he will miss the remainder of the regular season and potentially the postseason. In early November, Day offered his most detailed comments yet: the injury is healing and the long-term prognosis is good, but “it’s not gonna be next week or next month. It’s gonna take some time.” Reports have indicated a right elbow fracture that required surgery. Sayin remains around the team, participating in meetings and providing support, but he is not close to returning to the field.
That absence has forced true freshman Luke Fahey into the starting role. Fahey has shown toughness and the ability to move the ball at times, throwing for significant yardage in the Oregon game. But he is still learning under fire. The offense has lacked rhythm for long stretches. Red-zone efficiency has suffered. Jeremiah Smith, the team’s best player, has gone extended periods without targets in critical moments.
The quarterback problem is not only about Fahey’s inexperience. It is also about roster construction. Previous depth options transferred, leaving the program thinner than it should have been when the starter went down. Day has stuck with Fahey, saying he currently gives the team the best chance to win while keeping Tavien St. Clair ready. Supporting the young quarterback with a simplified plan, higher-percentage throws, and consistent involvement of Smith is essential. Asking Fahey to carry an offense that is not functioning around him is a recipe for continued frustration.
Problem 3: Coaching Decisions and the Failure to Adjust
The third and most controllable problem sits with the coaching staff itself. Ohio State has shown a repeated pattern of letting games spiral once momentum shifts. A 20-point lead disappeared against Texas. A 14-0 lead evaporated against Oregon. In both cases, the staff struggled to find answers in real time.
Special teams failures reached a breaking point with the Oregon fake punt that flipped the game, leading to the firing of coordinator Robby Discher. Offensive play-calling has at times left Smith uninvolved for long stretches even as the offense stagnated. Defensive adjustments have been slow. Day has taken ownership, stating that losing three games is unacceptable and that accountability starts with the staff. He has said the program must evaluate everything.
That evaluation needs to produce visible changes quickly. Simplifying the offense for Fahey, designing more decisive ways to get Smith the ball early, generating consistent pressure on defense, and cleaning up the self-inflicted mistakes (penalties, special-teams breakdowns, and mental lapses) are all within the staff’s control. Continuing to hope the same approaches suddenly work is not a plan.
The Path Forward Before It’s Too Late
Northwestern arrives this weekend. It is a home game and the clearest opportunity to stop the bleeding. The remaining schedule against Nebraska and Michigan will test whether the program can still respond to adversity.
The three problems are linked. A more functional offense that protects Fahey and features Smith reduces the burden on the defense. A defense that stops giving up explosives gives the offense room to operate. Coaching decisions that prioritize simplicity, accountability, and rapid adjustment give both sides a better chance.
Julian Sayin’s injury removed the team’s highest-upside quarterback at the worst possible time. The long-term outlook for his recovery appears positive, but that does nothing for the next three weeks. Ohio State must play the hand it has been dealt. That means maximizing Fahey’s strengths, fixing the defensive leaks that have defined the recent losses, and making the in-game and structural coaching adjustments that have been missing.
Day has repeatedly said the standards at Ohio State do not change. The results of the last three losses show those standards have not been met. The remaining schedule will reveal whether the program still has the ability — and the will — to meet them before the season ends on a note of deeper disappointment. The problems are clear. The time to fix them is now.




