Jeremiah Smith remains the most dangerous player on Ohio State’s roster and one of the most dominant wide receivers in recent college football history. After a stretch in the Oregon game where he went more than 32 minutes without a target, questions about his usage, frustration, and even whether he should continue playing this season have dominated the conversation. Offensive coordinator Arthur Smith addressed those concerns directly this week and made the program’s stance clear: Smith stays central to the offense, and getting him the ball remains a constant priority.
The Oregon Stretch That Sparked the Debate
In Ohio State’s 41-28 loss to Oregon, Smith finished with seven catches for 133 yards and a touchdown. On the surface those numbers look solid. Dig deeper and the distribution tells a different story. After hauling in his third reception with 2:59 left in the first quarter, Smith did not see another target until the final seconds of the third quarter. That drought lasted roughly 32 minutes and 44 seconds of game time. Much of his production, including the late touchdown, came after Oregon had already built a large lead and the outcome was essentially decided.
Smith’s visible frustration on the sideline during that long stretch was noticeable. Analysts and fans noticed. The Buckeyes’ offense, already dealing with a true freshman quarterback in Luke Fahey and broader execution issues, struggled to find rhythm once Oregon seized control. When the best player on the field is not involved for long stretches of a competitive game, the play-calling and offensive structure come under scrutiny.
Arthur Smith’s Clear Response
Arthur Smith did not dodge the questions. He confirmed the staff constantly tracks Smith’s opportunities. “Oh, absolutely,” he said when asked if he monitors stretches when Smith is not involved. He pointed out that Smith is already one of the most targeted receivers in college football and that multiple factors can influence where the ball goes on any given play—coverage, protection, or subtle breakdowns elsewhere in the concept.
“It’s always the focus,” Smith said of getting the star receiver more involved. He went further: “We’d love to have him touch the ball every play.” At the same time, he acknowledged the reality that defenses dictate some of the outcomes. Double teams, bracket coverages, and the need to keep the offense balanced mean Smith cannot literally see the ball on every snap. Still, the coordinator’s message left little ambiguity. Maximizing Smith’s involvement is not a new talking point that appeared after the Oregon loss. It is a weekly priority.
Historic Production That Raises the Stakes
Smith’s 2026 numbers put the usage debate in sharp context. Through nine games he has 69 receptions for 1,200 yards and 14 touchdowns, averaging 17.4 yards per catch. He continues to climb career charts and already owns the Big Ten record for receiving touchdowns. His combination of size, speed, contested-catch ability, and yards after the catch makes him a weekly mismatch.
That production is why outside voices began arguing that Smith has little left to gain by continuing to play. After the Oregon defeat dropped Ohio State to 6-3 and essentially ended realistic College Football Playoff hopes, former Alabama running back and CBS analyst Damien Harris publicly suggested Smith should shut down the rest of the season. Harris argued the receiver has already secured his place in program and conference history, a national championship, and a projected top selection in the 2027 NFL Draft. From a pure risk-reward standpoint, Harris said, there is “nothing to gain and everything to lose.”
Those comments reflect a broader conversation that surfaces whenever elite prospects play for teams that fall out of title contention. Load management and draft protection have become part of the modern college football discussion, especially with NIL and the transfer portal changing incentives.
Why Ohio State Is Not Shutting Him Down
Ohio State’s response has been consistent. Arthur Smith’s comments make clear the staff still views Smith as the focal point of the passing game for the remaining schedule. There has been no indication from the coaching staff or from Smith himself that he intends to sit out the final three regular-season games against Northwestern, Nebraska, and Michigan.
Several factors explain the stance. First, Smith has shown no public desire to walk away. He has been one of the most competitive and durable players on the roster throughout his career. Second, even in a disappointing team season, individual performance and leadership still matter inside the building. Third, Ohio State still has meaningful games left, including the rivalry matchup with Michigan. For a player of Smith’s caliber and competitive makeup, finishing those games carries weight beyond draft stock.
There is also a practical offensive reality. With Julian Sayin out and Fahey still developing, Smith is the clearest path to explosive plays. When the offense has struggled to sustain drives or convert in the red zone, the best available solution is usually to get the ball into the hands of the most talented player on the field as often as possible.
Balancing Focus and Creativity
The criticism of Smith’s usage is not simply about total targets. It is about timing and creativity. Joel Klatt and others pointed out after the Oregon game that the plan sometimes appeared to be lining Smith up and hoping the coverage allowed a throw rather than designing specific ways to free him against heavy attention. Arthur Smith’s comments suggest the staff is aware of those stretches and continues to search for solutions within the flow of the game.
Defenses will continue to key on Smith. That attention should open opportunities for other receivers if the offense can execute. At the same time, the staff must avoid long periods where the best player is essentially a decoy. The balance is difficult, especially with a young quarterback and an offensive line that has been inconsistent. Arthur Smith’s public commitment to keep Smith central is the clearest signal of how Ohio State intends to approach the final stretch.
What Comes Next
Northwestern visits Ohio Stadium this Saturday. It is a chance for the Buckeyes to stop a two-game slide and for the offense to re-establish rhythm with Smith as the featured piece. Nebraska and Michigan follow. Whether Ohio State can generate the consistent involvement Arthur Smith described will be one of the main storylines of the remaining regular season.
Jeremiah Smith has already built a résumé that ranks among the best in Ohio State and Big Ten history. The debate over whether he should continue playing is understandable from a pure NFL Draft risk perspective. The program’s response, delivered through its offensive coordinator, is equally clear: Smith remains a centerpiece of the offense, the staff is tracking his opportunities closely, and the goal is still to get him the ball as often as the game allows.
For a player of his talent and a program trying to finish a difficult season with pride, that plan makes sense. The coming weeks will show how effectively Ohio State can execute it.




